Madison Bumgarner single handedly carried the Giants to a World Series title earning MVP. 21 IP, 0.43 ERA, 2 W, 1 SV, 17 SO. A performance so dominant it might never be matched again. So the question has to be asked, who would you rather have? Clayton Kershaw the eventual Cy Young award winner, who already has two to his name. Or Madison Bumgarner with no Cy Young awards, but 3 World Series titles. Note: Clayton Kershaw has never pitched in the World Series.